//
archives

Discovery

This category contains 4 posts

Whose advice is it?

The Supreme Court decision granting leave to appeal the Court of Appeal decision regarding the disclosure of legal opinions and advice obtained by the trustees in Addleman v Lambie Trustee Limited (see Rights in information prevail) raises the thorny question, regarding how advice belongs to, or must be disclosed to, when legal advice is sought … Continue reading

The distinction between discovery and disclosure

The distinction between discovery and disclosure can appear esoteric and academic.  However, as identified in Hoeberechts v Sprott each serves a different function, the purpose of which warrants the relevant reflection.  The temptation, whichever is being sought is overreach.  Importantly less truly can be more, and more, can result in so much less that forward propulsion … Continue reading

It’s my trust and I’ll do as I like

“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, …” Thus commenced Charles Dickens’ novel A Tale of Two Cities, and similarly the mindset of any settlor of … Continue reading

David and Goliath?

Pertinent facts: On first blush Biggs v Biggs has the appearance of a David and Goliath style contest.   Nation J refers at [10] to the 2300 pages of documents that have had to be considered and at [11] notes that when claims are pursued “in a particular way, there can be scant recognition of the … Continue reading

Categories